Hickory Moisture not Equalizing with Subfloor

Flooring Forum

Help Support Flooring Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

PNWMax

New Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2025
Messages
1
Location
Washington
I purchased some hickory hardwood flooring 3 months ago. Life happened, and it has been sitting out for 3 months "acclimating" in the space it will be installed in.

My 40 year old subfloor on the second floor above a finished garage in the pacific northwest was at 12% moisture. I installed 1/2" underlayment 3 months ago, and measuring both together is still 12%. The hickory hardwood measures 7.5% on average. For a couple months I had it laying flat on the floor, and the last month I tried cross stacking it. The moisture content of the hickory hasn't measurably changed since I got it. The flooring is 3.5" wide, and the manufacturer recommends installing within 3% moisture content. The subfloor and hickory aren't really changing at all. I have started measuring the exact same spots week to week with no change. I'm using a Lignomat SDM scanner measuring at 3/4" and changing the wood species for the subfloor and hickory.

One interesting point is that if I measure at 1/4" on the subfloor, I'm about 2% difference from the hickory. I just can't get the numbers to match if I measure the subfloor at 3/4" (underlayment into the original subfloor).

For reference, I measured the red oak hardwood that has been installed in a different area for more than 10 years and it is a steady 10%, half way between the subfloor and hickory. I had to sand the oak down a few years ago because it was cupped, and I really just want to avoid a repeat performance of that.

It seems like with 3 months of acclimation and no change week to week, maybe it would be ok to install, but I really don't want to have future issues due to the differing moisture content and this being hickory.

Thoughts?
 
If it was my own house would be inclined to throw the wood in and be done with that portion of the install. You can hold off on the sanding portion until life gives you a break at another point down the road. You’ll know for sure it’s been properly acclimated by then.
 
What caused the oak floor to cup? Was it cupping from the get go or did something change that affected its environment which brought about the cupping? Maybe you have a wood stove or a dehumidifier that is excessively drying out the air. Could that also be affecting the acclimation time of your hickory?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top