The scary thing is, she was actually a judge in family court. She made life-altering decisions & ruined some lives.Judge Judy reminds me of a real judge. Some of her decisions make no sense at all.
I like Judge Milian. She used to be a prosecutor and she's married to a cop. I also like Judge Alex, who used to be a cop (I still remember the time he spent several minutes explaining exactly how to balance a checkbook to some jerk who was trying to stiff his ex on child support by voiding the checks after sending them to her). Mathis is a clown, but he's entertaining-- and I think more reasonable than Judy most of the time.
When my elderly friend, Cordell, was still alive we used to go over and have coffee (well, my mother had coffee, I would have water) and watch the judge shows with him. I still remember his face the time they had a plaintiff in the courtroom who looked like she only weighed 100lbs soaking wet & when she was asked what her profession was, she said roofing and drywall installation. On a commercial break, Cordell said something along the lines of "That little girl does roofing and drywall? Golleeeee" (sort of like how Andy Taylor would say it).